Consumer Choice
Shop the Consumer Choice collection at Don's Furniture Mattress (Columbus, OH) in Lancaster, OH. This curated collection highlights top-rated furniture picks across living room, bedroom, dining room, and more — pieces recognized for their combination of quality construction, everyday value, and on-trend style. If you're looking for furniture that has been vetted for comfort, durability, and customer satisfaction, the Consumer Choice collection is a great place to start. Whether you're furnishing a new home or refreshing a single room, these selections make shopping easier by narrowing the field to proven favorites. Browse sofas, bedroom sets, dining tables, accent pieces, and more from the collection. Visit our furniture showroom in Lancaster to see Consumer Choice pieces on display, or browse the full collection online. Our team is here to help you find the right pieces for your home. Delivery and flexible financing are available throughout the Lancaster, OH area. Financing options available.
-
Original price $1,078.99Original price $1,078.99 - Original price $1,078.99Original price $1,078.99Current price $829.99$829.99 - $829.99Current price $829.99
Burkhaus Dining Extension Table
Ashley FurnitureDressed to thrill, this simply stunning dining table offers a high-design look at a down-to-earth price. Ultra sleek lines are accentuated with a d...
View full detailsOriginal price $1,078.99Original price $1,078.99 - Original price $1,078.99Original price $1,078.99Current price $829.99$829.99 - $829.99Current price $829.99Save 23% -
Original price $1,403.99Original price $1,403.99 - Original price $1,403.99Original price $1,403.99Current price $1,079.99$1,079.99 - $1,079.99Current price $1,079.99
Burkhaus Dining Server
Ashley FurnitureDressed to thrill, this simply stunning dining server offers a high-design look at a down-to-earth price. Ultra sleek lines are accentuated with a ...
View full detailsOriginal price $1,403.99Original price $1,403.99 - Original price $1,403.99Original price $1,403.99Current price $1,079.99$1,079.99 - $1,079.99Current price $1,079.99Save 23% -
Original price $1,585.99 - Original price $4,458.99Original price $1,585.99 - Original price $4,458.99Original price $1,585.99$1,219.99 - $3,429.99$1,219.99 - $3,429.99Current price $1,219.99
Burkhaus Dining Room Set
Ashley FurnitureDressed to thrill, this simply stunning dining package offers a high-design look at a down-to-earth price. Ultra-sleek lines are accentuated with a...
View full detailsOriginal price $1,585.99 - Original price $4,458.99Original price $1,585.99 - Original price $4,458.99Original price $1,585.99$1,219.99 - $3,429.99$1,219.99 - $3,429.99Current price $1,219.99Save up to 23% -
Original price $311.99Original price $311.99 - Original price $311.99Original price $311.99Current price $239.99$239.99 - $239.99Current price $239.99
Cabalynn 63" Dining Bench
Ashley FurnitureThis dining bench sits comfortably at the intersection of modern lodge and farmhouse aesthetics. Your warm and welcoming disposition is reflected i...
View full detailsOriginal price $311.99Original price $311.99 - Original price $311.99Original price $311.99Current price $239.99$239.99 - $239.99Current price $239.99Save 23% -
Original price $1,767.99 - Original price $1,988.99Original price $1,767.99 - Original price $1,988.99Original price $1,767.99$1,359.99 - $1,529.99$1,359.99 - $1,529.99Current price $1,359.99
Cabalynn Bed with Storage
Ashley FurnitureThis California king panel bed with storage sits comfortably at the intersection of modern lodge and farmhouse aesthetics. Your warm and welcoming ...
View full detailsOriginal price $1,767.99 - Original price $1,988.99Original price $1,767.99 - Original price $1,988.99Original price $1,767.99$1,359.99 - $1,529.99$1,359.99 - $1,529.99Current price $1,359.99Save up to 23% -
Original price $1,507.99Original price $1,507.99 - Original price $1,507.99Original price $1,507.99Current price $1,159.99$1,159.99 - $1,159.99Current price $1,159.99
Cabalynn Chest of Drawers
Ashley FurnitureThis chest sits comfortably at the intersection of modern lodge and farmhouse aesthetics. Your warm and welcoming disposition is reflected in the c...
View full detailsOriginal price $1,507.99Original price $1,507.99 - Original price $1,507.99Original price $1,507.99Current price $1,159.99$1,159.99 - $1,159.99Current price $1,159.99Save 23% -
Original price $1,286.99Original price $1,286.99 - Original price $1,286.99Original price $1,286.99Current price $989.99$989.99 - $989.99Current price $989.99
Cabalynn Dining Extension Table
Ashley FurnitureThis dining extension table sits comfortably at the intersection of modern lodge and farmhouse aesthetics. Your warm and welcoming disposition is r...
View full detailsOriginal price $1,286.99Original price $1,286.99 - Original price $1,286.99Original price $1,286.99Current price $989.99$989.99 - $989.99Current price $989.99Save 23% -
Original price $220.99Original price $220.99 - Original price $220.99Original price $220.99Current price $169.99$169.99 - $169.99Current price $169.99
Cabalynn Dining Chair
Ashley FurnitureThis dining chair sits comfortably at the intersection of modern lodge and farmhouse aesthetics. Your warm and welcoming disposition is reflected i...
View full detailsOriginal price $220.99Original price $220.99 - Original price $220.99Original price $220.99Current price $169.99$169.99 - $169.99Current price $169.99Save 23% -
Original price $1,299.99 - Original price $3,002.99Original price $1,299.99 - Original price $3,002.99Original price $1,299.99$999.99 - $2,309.99$999.99 - $2,309.99Current price $999.99
Cabalynn Dining Room Set
Ashley FurnitureThis dining package sits comfortably at the intersection of modern lodge and farmhouse aesthetics. Your warm and welcoming disposition is reflected...
View full detailsOriginal price $1,299.99 - Original price $3,002.99Original price $1,299.99 - Original price $3,002.99Original price $1,299.99$999.99 - $2,309.99$999.99 - $2,309.99Current price $999.99Save up to 23% -
Original price $1,468.99Original price $1,468.99 - Original price $1,468.99Original price $1,468.99Current price $1,129.99$1,129.99 - $1,129.99Current price $1,129.99
Cabalynn Dresser
Ashley FurnitureThis dresser sits comfortably at the intersection of modern lodge and farmhouse aesthetics. Your warm and welcoming disposition is reflected in the...
View full detailsOriginal price $1,468.99Original price $1,468.99 - Original price $1,468.99Original price $1,468.99Current price $1,129.99$1,129.99 - $1,129.99Current price $1,129.99Save 23% -
Original price $1,715.99Original price $1,715.99 - Original price $1,715.99Original price $1,715.99Current price $1,319.99$1,319.99 - $1,319.99Current price $1,319.99
Cabalynn Dresser and Mirror
Ashley FurnitureThis dresser with mirror sits comfortably at the intersection of modern lodge and farmhouse aesthetics. Your warm and welcoming disposition is refl...
View full detailsOriginal price $1,715.99Original price $1,715.99 - Original price $1,715.99Original price $1,715.99Current price $1,319.99$1,319.99 - $1,319.99Current price $1,319.99Save 23% -
Original price $545.99Original price $545.99 - Original price $545.99Original price $545.99Current price $419.99$419.99 - $419.99Current price $419.99
Cabalynn Nightstand
Ashley FurnitureThis nightstand sits comfortably at the intersection of modern lodge and farmhouse aesthetics. Your warm and welcoming disposition is reflected in ...
View full detailsOriginal price $545.99Original price $545.99 - Original price $545.99Original price $545.99Current price $419.99$419.99 - $419.99Current price $419.99Save 23% -
Original price $1,078.99 - Original price $1,260.99Original price $1,078.99 - Original price $1,260.99Original price $1,078.99$829.99 - $969.99$829.99 - $969.99Current price $829.99
Cabalynn Upholstered Bed
Ashley FurnitureThis California king upholstered bed sits comfortably at the intersection of modern lodge and farmhouse aesthetics. Your warm and welcoming disposi...
View full detailsOriginal price $1,078.99 - Original price $1,260.99Original price $1,078.99 - Original price $1,260.99Original price $1,078.99$829.99 - $969.99$829.99 - $969.99Current price $829.99Save up to 23% -
Original price $701.99Original price $701.99 - Original price $701.99Original price $701.99Current price $539.99$539.99 - $539.99Current price $539.99
Cadmori Dresser
Ashley FurnitureTransform your bedroom with this dresser. With its clean lines and replicated marble top, it exudes a minimal and sophisticated boho style. Tailor ...
View full detailsOriginal price $701.99Original price $701.99 - Original price $701.99Original price $701.99Current price $539.99$539.99 - $539.99Current price $539.99Save 23% -
Original price $506.99Original price $506.99 - Original price $506.99Original price $506.99Current price $389.99$389.99 - $389.99Current price $389.99
Cadmori Nightstand
Ashley FurnitureTransform your bedroom with this nightstand. With its clean lines and replicated marble top, it exudes a minimal and sophisticated boho style. Buil...
View full detailsOriginal price $506.99Original price $506.99 - Original price $506.99Original price $506.99Current price $389.99$389.99 - $389.99Current price $389.99Save 23% -
Original price $454.99Original price $454.99 - Original price $454.99Original price $454.99Current price $349.99$349.99 - $349.99Current price $349.99
Cariton End Table Set
Ashley FurnitureThis 2-piece end table set makes it hip to be square. Bold, blocky profile is enriched with plank-effect styling and a textured grayish brown finis...
View full detailsOriginal price $454.99Original price $454.99 - Original price $454.99Original price $454.99Current price $349.99$349.99 - $349.99Current price $349.99Save 23% -
Original price $831.99Original price $831.99 - Original price $831.99Original price $831.99Current price $639.99$639.99 - $639.99Current price $639.99
Cariton Occasional Table Set
Ashley FurnitureThis occasional table set masters the art of simplicity. Bold, blocky profile is enriched with plank-effect styling and a textured grayish brown fi...
View full detailsOriginal price $831.99Original price $831.99 - Original price $831.99Original price $831.99Current price $639.99$639.99 - $639.99Current price $639.99Save 23% -
Original price $610.99Original price $610.99 - Original price $610.99Original price $610.99Current price $469.99$469.99 - $469.99Current price $469.99
Cariton Table Set
Ashley FurnitureThis occasional table set masters the art of simplicity. Bold, blocky profile is enriched with plank-effect styling and a textured grayish brown fi...
View full detailsOriginal price $610.99Original price $610.99 - Original price $610.99Original price $610.99Current price $469.99$469.99 - $469.99Current price $469.99Save 23% -
Original price $662.99Original price $662.99 - Original price $662.99Original price $662.99Current price $509.99$509.99 - $509.99Current price $509.99
Carynhurst End Table Set
Ashley FurnitureAdd a quaint touch of farmhouse style to your living area with this 2-piece end table set. Its beautifully distressed light gray finish enhances th...
View full detailsOriginal price $662.99Original price $662.99 - Original price $662.99Original price $662.99Current price $509.99$509.99 - $509.99Current price $509.99Save 23% -
Original price $1,104.99 - Original price $1,403.99Original price $1,104.99 - Original price $1,403.99Original price $1,104.99$849.99 - $1,079.99$849.99 - $1,079.99Current price $849.99
Carynhurst Home Office Set
Ashley FurnitureLooking for a fresh approach to modern farmhouse living? This home office set works on so many levels. Clean-lined profiles with crossbuck backs ne...
View full detailsOriginal price $1,104.99 - Original price $1,403.99Original price $1,104.99 - Original price $1,403.99Original price $1,104.99$849.99 - $1,079.99$849.99 - $1,079.99Current price $849.99Save up to 23% -
Original price $610.99 - Original price $1,507.99Original price $610.99 - Original price $1,507.99Original price $610.99$469.99 - $1,159.99$469.99 - $1,159.99Current price $469.99
Carynhurst Occasional Table Set
Ashley FurnitureUnlock a quaint touch of farmhouse style and convenience in your living area with this occasional table set. Inspired by the rugged looks of antiqu...
View full detailsOriginal price $610.99 - Original price $1,507.99Original price $610.99 - Original price $1,507.99Original price $610.99$469.99 - $1,159.99$469.99 - $1,159.99Current price $469.99Save up to 23% -
Original price $1,169.99Original price $1,169.99 - Original price $1,169.99Original price $1,169.99Current price $899.99$899.99 - $899.99Current price $899.99
Carynhurst Table Set
Ashley FurnitureUnlock a quaint touch of farmhouse style and convenience in your living area with this occasional table set. Inspired by the rugged looks of antiqu...
View full detailsOriginal price $1,169.99Original price $1,169.99 - Original price $1,169.99Original price $1,169.99Current price $899.99$899.99 - $899.99Current price $899.99Save 23% -
Original price $285.99 - Original price $506.99Original price $285.99 - Original price $506.99Original price $285.99$219.99 - $389.99$219.99 - $389.99Current price $219.99
Cayboni Bed
Ashley FurnitureCharmingly designed, this queen panel bed embraces the aesthetics of countryside living and repurposes them for modern settings. Its whitewash pain...
View full detailsOriginal price $285.99 - Original price $506.99Original price $285.99 - Original price $506.99Original price $285.99$219.99 - $389.99$219.99 - $389.99Current price $219.99Save up to 23% -
Original price $792.99 - Original price $1,208.99Original price $792.99 - Original price $1,208.99Original price $792.99$609.99 - $929.99$609.99 - $929.99Current price $609.99
Cayboni Bedroom Package
Ashley FurnitureMore About This Product Weight & Dimensions Dimensions Full Dimension --W x --D x --H Weight Weight 15lbs.
Original price $792.99 - Original price $1,208.99Original price $792.99 - Original price $1,208.99Original price $792.99$609.99 - $929.99$609.99 - $929.99Current price $609.99Save up to 23%
Consumer Choice — Frequently Asked Questions
What is the Consumer Choice collection?
Consumer Choice gathers the pieces our customers love most at Don's Furniture Mattress (Columbus, OH) — the styles that get chosen, reviewed well, and reordered again and again. Think of it as a shortcut to our proven favorites.
Why should I shop Consumer Choice?
If you want something dependable without combing through the entire catalog, this is a great place to start — it's a curated shortlist of best-sellers from Ashley Furniture that have already won people over.
Do you deliver Consumer Choice items?
Yes. We deliver throughout our local service area — see our shipping & delivery policy for timelines and coverage, or contact us for a quote.
Can I finance a Consumer Choice purchase?
Yes. We offer financing options on qualifying purchases, often with promotional low- or no-interest plans.
Can I see these items in person?
Many of our most popular pieces are on display in the showroom, though the floor selection rotates. Please contact us to confirm a specific item is available to view before you visit.
What if my item arrives damaged?
Inspect it at delivery, note any damage on the paperwork, take photos, and contact us right away. We'll arrange a repair, replacement, or return under our return policy.