Consumer Choice
Shop the Consumer Choice collection at Don's Furniture Mattress (Columbus, OH) in Lancaster, OH. This curated collection highlights top-rated furniture picks across living room, bedroom, dining room, and more — pieces recognized for their combination of quality construction, everyday value, and on-trend style. If you're looking for furniture that has been vetted for comfort, durability, and customer satisfaction, the Consumer Choice collection is a great place to start. Whether you're furnishing a new home or refreshing a single room, these selections make shopping easier by narrowing the field to proven favorites. Browse sofas, bedroom sets, dining tables, accent pieces, and more from the collection. Visit our furniture showroom in Lancaster to see Consumer Choice pieces on display, or browse the full collection online. Our team is here to help you find the right pieces for your home. Delivery and flexible financing are available throughout the Lancaster, OH area. Financing options available.
-
Original price $64.99 - Original price $77.99Original price $64.99 - Original price $77.99Original price $64.99$49.99 - $59.99$49.99 - $59.99Current price $49.99
Meadie Vase
Ashley FurnitureUnderstated in its beauty, this vase offers a traditional feel courtesy of its terra cotta construction. The antiqued look is brought into the pres...
View full detailsOriginal price $64.99 - Original price $77.99Original price $64.99 - Original price $77.99Original price $64.99$49.99 - $59.99$49.99 - $59.99Current price $49.99Save up to 23% -
Original price $1,416.99 - Original price $3,431.99Original price $1,416.99 - Original price $3,431.99Original price $1,416.99$1,089.99 - $2,639.99$1,089.99 - $2,639.99Current price $1,089.99
Midnight-Madness Sectional with Chaise
Ashley FurnitureWrapped in luxuriously soft jumbo corduroy, this sectional with chaise takes cozy and inviting to a higher level. The sumptuous piece is perfect fo...
View full detailsOriginal price $1,416.99 - Original price $3,431.99Original price $1,416.99 - Original price $3,431.99Original price $1,416.99$1,089.99 - $2,639.99$1,089.99 - $2,639.99Current price $1,089.99Save up to 23% -
Original price $1,897.99 - Original price $2,833.99Original price $1,897.99 - Original price $2,833.99Original price $1,897.99$1,459.99 - $2,179.99$1,459.99 - $2,179.99Current price $1,459.99
Midnight-Madness Sectional
Ashley FurnitureWrapped in luxuriously soft jumbo corduroy, this sectional takes cozy and inviting to a higher level. The sumptuous piece is perfect for unwinding ...
View full detailsOriginal price $1,897.99 - Original price $2,833.99Original price $1,897.99 - Original price $2,833.99Original price $1,897.99$1,459.99 - $2,179.99$1,459.99 - $2,179.99Current price $1,459.99Save up to 23% -
Original price $3,145.99 - Original price $4,679.99Original price $3,145.99 - Original price $4,679.99Original price $3,145.99$2,419.99 - $3,599.99$2,419.99 - $3,599.99Current price $2,419.99
Modmax II Power Reclining Sectional with Audio Consoles
Ashley FurnitureLooking cool and contemporary is great. But when it comes down to it, you’re all about low-maintenance lounging. With the performance fabric on thi...
View full detailsOriginal price $3,145.99 - Original price $4,679.99Original price $3,145.99 - Original price $4,679.99Original price $3,145.99$2,419.99 - $3,599.99$2,419.99 - $3,599.99Current price $2,419.99Save up to 23% -
Original price $1,585.99Original price $1,585.99 - Original price $1,585.99Original price $1,585.99Current price $1,219.99$1,219.99 - $1,219.99Current price $1,219.99
Modmax II Reclining Loveseat
Ashley FurnitureLooking cool and contemporary is great. But when it comes down to it, you’re all about low-maintenance lounging. With the performance fabric on thi...
View full detailsOriginal price $1,585.99Original price $1,585.99 - Original price $1,585.99Original price $1,585.99Current price $1,219.99$1,219.99 - $1,219.99Current price $1,219.99Save 23% -
Original price $2,235.99Original price $2,235.99 - Original price $2,235.99Original price $2,235.99Current price $1,719.99$1,719.99 - $1,719.99Current price $1,719.99
Modmax II Reclining Sofa Chaise
Ashley FurnitureLooking cool and contemporary is great. But when it comes down to it, you’re all about low-maintenance lounging. With the performance fabric on thi...
View full detailsOriginal price $2,235.99Original price $2,235.99 - Original price $2,235.99Original price $2,235.99Current price $1,719.99$1,719.99 - $1,719.99Current price $1,719.99Save 23% -
Original price $727.99Original price $727.99 - Original price $727.99Original price $727.99Current price $559.99$559.99 - $559.99Current price $559.99
Caitbrook Dining Set
Ashley FurniturePerfect portion. Striking a simply chic pose, this dining package serves up high style on a smaller scale. Its antiqued gray wash finish gives the ...
View full detailsOriginal price $727.99Original price $727.99 - Original price $727.99Original price $727.99Current price $559.99$559.99 - $559.99Current price $559.99Save 23% -
Original price $246.99Original price $246.99 - Original price $246.99Original price $246.99Current price $189.99$189.99 - $189.99Current price $189.99
Caitbrook Bar Height Bar Stool
Ashley FurnitureBring a relaxed yet refined sense of good taste to a space with this upholstered swivel bar stool. The sturdy wood frame with contoured backrest is...
View full detailsOriginal price $246.99Original price $246.99 - Original price $246.99Original price $246.99Current price $189.99$189.99 - $189.99Current price $189.99Save 23% -
Original price $103.99 - Original price $142.99Original price $103.99 - Original price $142.99Original price $103.99$79.99 - $109.99$79.99 - $109.99Current price $79.99
Caitbrook Counter Height Upholstered Bar Stool
Ashley FurnitureBring a relaxed yet refined sense of good taste to a space with this upholstered stool. The clean-lined frame sports a gray-washed finish that's so...
View full detailsOriginal price $103.99 - Original price $142.99Original price $103.99 - Original price $142.99Original price $103.99$79.99 - $109.99$79.99 - $109.99Current price $79.99Save up to 23% -
Original price $1,104.99Original price $1,104.99 - Original price $1,104.99Original price $1,104.99Current price $849.99$849.99 - $849.99Current price $849.99
Caitbrook Counter Height Dining Table and Bar Stools (Set of 7)
Ashley FurniturePerfect portion. Striking a simply chic pose, this counter height dining set is crafted with fascinating flair. A subtle gray wash finish gives the...
View full detailsOriginal price $1,104.99Original price $1,104.99 - Original price $1,104.99Original price $1,104.99Current price $849.99$849.99 - $849.99Current price $849.99Save 23% -
Original price $246.99Original price $246.99 - Original price $246.99Original price $246.99Current price $189.99$189.99 - $189.99Current price $189.99
Caitbrook Counter Height Bar Stool
Ashley FurnitureBring a relaxed yet refined sense of good taste to a space with this upholstered swivel bar stool. The sturdy wood frame with contoured backrest is...
View full detailsOriginal price $246.99Original price $246.99 - Original price $246.99Original price $246.99Current price $189.99$189.99 - $189.99Current price $189.99Save 23% -
Original price $727.99 - Original price $1,000.99Original price $727.99 - Original price $1,000.99Original price $727.99$559.99 - $769.99$559.99 - $769.99Current price $559.99
Caitbrook Counter Height Dining Package
Ashley FurniturePerfect portion. Striking a simply chic pose, this dining package serves up high style on a smaller scale. Its antiqued gray wash finish gives the ...
View full detailsOriginal price $727.99 - Original price $1,000.99Original price $727.99 - Original price $1,000.99Original price $727.99$559.99 - $769.99$559.99 - $769.99Current price $559.99Save up to 23% -
Original price $987.99Original price $987.99 - Original price $987.99Original price $987.99Current price $759.99$759.99 - $759.99Current price $759.99
Caitbrook Dining Table and Chairs (Set of 7)
Ashley FurniturePerfect portion. Striking a simply chic pose, this dining set is styled with fascinating flair. Subtle gray wash finish gives the clean-lined desig...
View full detailsOriginal price $987.99Original price $987.99 - Original price $987.99Original price $987.99Current price $759.99$759.99 - $759.99Current price $759.99Save 23% -
Original price $441.99Original price $441.99 - Original price $441.99Original price $441.99Current price $339.99$339.99 - $339.99Current price $339.99
Caitbrook Counter Height Dining Table
Ashley FurniturePerfect portion. Striking a simply chic pose, this dining room counter table serves up high style on a smaller scale. Its antiqued gray wash finish...
View full detailsOriginal price $441.99Original price $441.99 - Original price $441.99Original price $441.99Current price $339.99$339.99 - $339.99Current price $339.99Save 23% -
Original price $2,170.99 - Original price $2,729.99Original price $2,170.99 - Original price $2,729.99Original price $2,170.99$1,669.99 - $2,099.99$1,669.99 - $2,099.99Current price $1,669.99
Ashbryn Bedroom Package
Ashley FurnitureCasual style with substance. This two-tone bedroom package raises the bar on comfortably cozy design in your soothing sanctuary. Charmingly curated...
View full detailsOriginal price $2,170.99 - Original price $2,729.99Original price $2,170.99 - Original price $2,729.99Original price $2,170.99$1,669.99 - $2,099.99$1,669.99 - $2,099.99Current price $1,669.99Save up to 23% -
Original price $428.99 - Original price $701.99Original price $428.99 - Original price $701.99Original price $428.99$329.99 - $539.99$329.99 - $539.99Current price $329.99
Cambeck Bed
Ashley FurnitureWhat a delightful take on rustic industrial style. Whether modern loft or modern farmhouse, this queen panel bed makes itself at home. The wispy wh...
View full detailsOriginal price $428.99 - Original price $701.99Original price $428.99 - Original price $701.99Original price $428.99$329.99 - $539.99$329.99 - $539.99Current price $329.99Save up to 23% -
Original price $649.99 - Original price $1,104.99Original price $649.99 - Original price $1,104.99Original price $649.99$499.99 - $849.99$499.99 - $849.99Current price $499.99
Cambeck Bed with 2 Storage Drawers
Ashley FurnitureWhat a delightful take on rustic industrial style. Whether modern loft or modern farmhouse, this queen panel storage bed makes itself at home. The ...
View full detailsOriginal price $649.99 - Original price $1,104.99Original price $649.99 - Original price $1,104.99Original price $649.99$499.99 - $849.99$499.99 - $849.99Current price $499.99Save up to 23% -
Original price $1,078.99 - Original price $1,390.99Original price $1,078.99 - Original price $1,390.99Original price $1,078.99$829.99 - $1,069.99$829.99 - $1,069.99Current price $829.99
Cambeck Bed with 4 Storage Drawers
Ashley FurnitureWhat a delightful take on rustic industrial style. Whether modern loft or modern farmhouse, this queen panel storage bed makes itself at home. The ...
View full detailsOriginal price $1,078.99 - Original price $1,390.99Original price $1,078.99 - Original price $1,390.99Original price $1,078.99$829.99 - $1,069.99$829.99 - $1,069.99Current price $829.99Save up to 23% -
Original price $90.99Original price $90.99 - Original price $90.99Original price $90.99Current price $69.99$69.99 - $69.99Current price $69.99
Cambeck Bedroom Mirror
Ashley FurnitureWhat a delightful take on rustic industrial style. Whether modern loft or modern farmhouse, this mirror makes itself at home. The wispy whitewash p...
View full detailsOriginal price $90.99Original price $90.99 - Original price $90.99Original price $90.99Current price $69.99$69.99 - $69.99Current price $69.99Save 23% -
Original price $428.99Original price $428.99 - Original price $428.99Original price $428.99Current price $329.99$329.99 - $329.99Current price $329.99
Cambeck Chest of Drawers
Ashley FurnitureWhat a delightful take on rustic industrial style. Whether modern loft or modern farmhouse, this chest makes itself at home. The wispy whitewash pa...
View full detailsOriginal price $428.99Original price $428.99 - Original price $428.99Original price $428.99Current price $329.99$329.99 - $329.99Current price $329.99Save 23% -
Original price $454.99Original price $454.99 - Original price $454.99Original price $454.99Current price $349.99$349.99 - $349.99Current price $349.99
Cambeck Dresser
Ashley FurnitureWhat a delightful take on rustic industrial style. Whether modern loft or modern farmhouse, this dresser makes itself at home. The wispy whitewash ...
View full detailsOriginal price $454.99Original price $454.99 - Original price $454.99Original price $454.99Current price $349.99$349.99 - $349.99Current price $349.99Save 23% -
Original price $532.99Original price $532.99 - Original price $532.99Original price $532.99Current price $409.99$409.99 - $409.99Current price $409.99
Cambeck Dresser and Mirror
Ashley FurnitureWhat a delightful take on rustic industrial style. Whether modern loft or modern farmhouse, this dresser and mirror set makes itself at home. The w...
View full detailsOriginal price $532.99Original price $532.99 - Original price $532.99Original price $532.99Current price $409.99$409.99 - $409.99Current price $409.99Save 23% -
Original price $428.99Original price $428.99 - Original price $428.99Original price $428.99Current price $329.99$329.99 - $329.99Current price $329.99
Cambeck Narrow Chest of Drawers
Ashley FurnitureWhat a delightful take on rustic industrial style. Whether modern loft or modern farmhouse, this narrow chest makes itself at home. The wispy white...
View full detailsOriginal price $428.99Original price $428.99 - Original price $428.99Original price $428.99Current price $329.99$329.99 - $329.99Current price $329.99Save 23% -
Original price $298.99Original price $298.99 - Original price $298.99Original price $298.99Current price $229.99$229.99 - $229.99Current price $229.99
Cambeck Nightstand
Ashley FurnitureWhat a delightful take on rustic industrial style. Whether modern loft or modern farmhouse, this nightstand makes itself at home. The wispy whitewa...
View full detailsOriginal price $298.99Original price $298.99 - Original price $298.99Original price $298.99Current price $229.99$229.99 - $229.99Current price $229.99Save 23%
Consumer Choice — Frequently Asked Questions
What is the Consumer Choice collection?
Consumer Choice gathers the pieces our customers love most at Don's Furniture Mattress (Columbus, OH) — the styles that get chosen, reviewed well, and reordered again and again. Think of it as a shortcut to our proven favorites.
Why should I shop Consumer Choice?
If you want something dependable without combing through the entire catalog, this is a great place to start — it's a curated shortlist of best-sellers from Ashley Furniture that have already won people over.
Do you deliver Consumer Choice items?
Yes. We deliver throughout our local service area — see our shipping & delivery policy for timelines and coverage, or contact us for a quote.
Can I finance a Consumer Choice purchase?
Yes. We offer financing options on qualifying purchases, often with promotional low- or no-interest plans.
Can I see these items in person?
Many of our most popular pieces are on display in the showroom, though the floor selection rotates. Please contact us to confirm a specific item is available to view before you visit.
What if my item arrives damaged?
Inspect it at delivery, note any damage on the paperwork, take photos, and contact us right away. We'll arrange a repair, replacement, or return under our return policy.