Consumer Choice
Shop the Consumer Choice collection at Don's Furniture Mattress (Columbus, OH) in Lancaster, OH. This curated collection highlights top-rated furniture picks across living room, bedroom, dining room, and more — pieces recognized for their combination of quality construction, everyday value, and on-trend style. If you're looking for furniture that has been vetted for comfort, durability, and customer satisfaction, the Consumer Choice collection is a great place to start. Whether you're furnishing a new home or refreshing a single room, these selections make shopping easier by narrowing the field to proven favorites. Browse sofas, bedroom sets, dining tables, accent pieces, and more from the collection. Visit our furniture showroom in Lancaster to see Consumer Choice pieces on display, or browse the full collection online. Our team is here to help you find the right pieces for your home. Delivery and flexible financing are available throughout the Lancaster, OH area. Financing options available.
-
Original price $545.99Original price $545.99 - Original price $545.99Original price $545.99Current price $419.99$419.99 - $419.99Current price $419.99
Man Fort Recliner
Ashley FurnitureRoll out a cool look for your man cave or femme den with this indulgent recliner. Waterfall cushioning on the high chair back is paired with a doub...
View full detailsOriginal price $545.99Original price $545.99 - Original price $545.99Original price $545.99Current price $419.99$419.99 - $419.99Current price $419.99Save 23% -
Original price $1,520.99Original price $1,520.99 - Original price $1,520.99Original price $1,520.99Current price $1,169.99$1,169.99 - $1,169.99Current price $1,169.99
Leesworth Power Reclining Sofa
Ashley FurnitureFocus on function. This practical power reclining sofa balances contemporary character and irresistible comfort. Its affordable, expertly matched l...
View full detailsOriginal price $1,520.99Original price $1,520.99 - Original price $1,520.99Original price $1,520.99Current price $1,169.99$1,169.99 - $1,169.99Current price $1,169.99Save 23% -
Original price $1,416.99Original price $1,416.99 - Original price $1,416.99Original price $1,416.99Current price $1,089.99$1,089.99 - $1,089.99Current price $1,089.99
Leesworth Power Reclining Loveseat
Ashley FurnitureTalk about fine lines and great curves. That’s the beauty of this sofa chaise—made to suit your appreciation for clean, contemporary style. A strik...
View full detailsOriginal price $1,416.99Original price $1,416.99 - Original price $1,416.99Original price $1,416.99Current price $1,089.99$1,089.99 - $1,089.99Current price $1,089.99Save 23% -
Original price $2,924.99 - Original price $4,029.99Original price $2,924.99 - Original price $4,029.99Original price $2,924.99$2,249.99 - $3,099.99$2,249.99 - $3,099.99Current price $2,249.99
Leesworth Living Room Set
Ashley FurnitureFocus on function. This seating package balances contemporary character and irresistible comfort. Its affordable, expertly matched leather and faux...
View full detailsOriginal price $2,924.99 - Original price $4,029.99Original price $2,924.99 - Original price $4,029.99Original price $2,924.99$2,249.99 - $3,099.99$2,249.99 - $3,099.99Current price $2,249.99Save up to 23% -
Original price $1,104.99Original price $1,104.99 - Original price $1,104.99Original price $1,104.99Current price $849.99$849.99 - $849.99Current price $849.99
Leesworth Power Recliner
Ashley FurnitureTalk about fine lines and great curves. That’s the beauty of this sofa chaise—made to suit your appreciation for clean, contemporary style. A strik...
View full detailsOriginal price $1,104.99Original price $1,104.99 - Original price $1,104.99Original price $1,104.99Current price $849.99$849.99 - $849.99Current price $849.99Save 23% -
Original price $2,521.99 - Original price $3,990.99Original price $2,521.99 - Original price $3,990.99Original price $2,521.99$1,939.99 - $3,069.99$1,939.99 - $3,069.99Current price $1,939.99
Kincord Power Reclining Sectional
Ashley FurnitureYou could play it safe. Or you could choose to stand out in the crowd with this brilliantly styled sectional with power. Ultra cool, ultra contempo...
View full detailsOriginal price $2,521.99 - Original price $3,990.99Original price $2,521.99 - Original price $3,990.99Original price $2,521.99$1,939.99 - $3,069.99$1,939.99 - $3,069.99Current price $1,939.99Save up to 23% -
Original price $831.99Original price $831.99 - Original price $831.99Original price $831.99Current price $699.99$699.99 - $699.99Current price $699.99
Tulen Reclining Loveseat
Don's Furniture
This reclining loveseat puts the win in winning. Its waterfall back design and doubly plump pillowtop arms team up with soft chenille fabric to go ...
View full detailsOriginal price $831.99Original price $831.99 - Original price $831.99Original price $831.99Current price $699.99$699.99 - $699.99Current price $699.99Save 16% -
Original price $2,326.99 - Original price $3,522.99Original price $2,326.99 - Original price $3,522.99Original price $2,326.99$1,789.99 - $2,709.99$1,789.99 - $2,709.99Current price $1,789.99
Top Tier Reclining Sectional with Chaise
Ashley FurnitureExperience unparalleled comfort with this reclining sectional with chaise. It’s a stylish and invitingly soft look—made all the more appealing by c...
View full detailsOriginal price $2,326.99 - Original price $3,522.99Original price $2,326.99 - Original price $3,522.99Original price $2,326.99$1,789.99 - $2,709.99$1,789.99 - $2,709.99Current price $1,789.99Save up to 23% -
Original price $1,910.99Original price $1,910.99 - Original price $1,910.99Original price $1,910.99Current price $1,469.99$1,469.99 - $1,469.99Current price $1,469.99
Acklen Place Sectional
Ashley FurnitureEnjoy the endless adaptability of this power reclining sectional. Whether you’re hosting guests, setting up for movie night or just need a refresh,...
View full detailsOriginal price $1,910.99Original price $1,910.99 - Original price $1,910.99Original price $1,910.99Current price $1,469.99$1,469.99 - $1,469.99Current price $1,469.99Save 23% -
Original price $2,092.99Original price $2,092.99 - Original price $2,092.99Original price $2,092.99Current price $1,609.99$1,609.99 - $1,609.99Current price $1,609.99
Top Tier Sectional Chofa
Ashley FurnitureExperience unparalleled comfort with this sectional chofa. It’s a stylish and invitingly soft look—made all the more appealing by cozy corduroy cus...
View full detailsOriginal price $2,092.99Original price $2,092.99 - Original price $2,092.99Original price $2,092.99Current price $1,609.99$1,609.99 - $1,609.99Current price $1,609.99Save 23% -
Original price $844.99Original price $844.99 - Original price $844.99Original price $844.99Current price $649.99$649.99 - $649.99Current price $649.99
Schooner Rocks Power Recliner
Ashley FurnitureElevate your movie nights with this power recliner. Its adjustable headrest ensures a perfect view of the TV no matter how far back you recline, an...
View full detailsOriginal price $844.99Original price $844.99 - Original price $844.99Original price $844.99Current price $649.99$649.99 - $649.99Current price $649.99Save 23% -
Original price $3,145.99 - Original price $4,679.99Original price $3,145.99 - Original price $4,679.99Original price $3,145.99$2,419.99 - $3,599.99$2,419.99 - $3,599.99Current price $2,419.99
Modmax II Power Reclining Sectional with Audio Consoles
Ashley FurnitureLooking cool and contemporary is great. But when it comes down to it, you’re all about low-maintenance lounging. With the performance fabric on thi...
View full detailsOriginal price $3,145.99 - Original price $4,679.99Original price $3,145.99 - Original price $4,679.99Original price $3,145.99$2,419.99 - $3,599.99$2,419.99 - $3,599.99Current price $2,419.99Save up to 23% -
Original price $1,585.99Original price $1,585.99 - Original price $1,585.99Original price $1,585.99Current price $1,219.99$1,219.99 - $1,219.99Current price $1,219.99
Modmax II Reclining Loveseat
Ashley FurnitureLooking cool and contemporary is great. But when it comes down to it, you’re all about low-maintenance lounging. With the performance fabric on thi...
View full detailsOriginal price $1,585.99Original price $1,585.99 - Original price $1,585.99Original price $1,585.99Current price $1,219.99$1,219.99 - $1,219.99Current price $1,219.99Save 23% -
Original price $2,235.99Original price $2,235.99 - Original price $2,235.99Original price $2,235.99Current price $1,719.99$1,719.99 - $1,719.99Current price $1,719.99
Modmax II Reclining Sofa Chaise
Ashley FurnitureLooking cool and contemporary is great. But when it comes down to it, you’re all about low-maintenance lounging. With the performance fabric on thi...
View full detailsOriginal price $2,235.99Original price $2,235.99 - Original price $2,235.99Original price $2,235.99Current price $1,719.99$1,719.99 - $1,719.99Current price $1,719.99Save 23%
Consumer Choice — Frequently Asked Questions
What is the Consumer Choice collection?
Consumer Choice gathers the pieces our customers love most at Don's Furniture Mattress (Columbus, OH) — the styles that get chosen, reviewed well, and reordered again and again. Think of it as a shortcut to our proven favorites.
Why should I shop Consumer Choice?
If you want something dependable without combing through the entire catalog, this is a great place to start — it's a curated shortlist of best-sellers from Ashley Furniture, Don's Furniture that have already won people over.
Do you deliver Consumer Choice items?
Yes. We deliver throughout our local service area — see our shipping & delivery policy for timelines and coverage, or contact us for a quote.
Can I finance a Consumer Choice purchase?
Yes. We offer financing options on qualifying purchases, often with promotional low- or no-interest plans.
Can I see these items in person?
Many of our most popular pieces are on display in the showroom, though the floor selection rotates. Please contact us to confirm a specific item is available to view before you visit.
What if my item arrives damaged?
Inspect it at delivery, note any damage on the paperwork, take photos, and contact us right away. We'll arrange a repair, replacement, or return under our return policy.